Home / Research / State of AEO
Original Research · Published April 25, 2026 · Open methodology · ~22 min read

The 2026 State of Answer Engine Optimization Across Six Industries

An open-methodology study on how ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini name brands across six high-value verticals — and what separates the brands that get cited from the ones that get ignored.

1,200 prompts × four LLMs × six verticals. The flagship study.
1,200 prompts × four LLMs × six verticals. The flagship study.

Abstract

Between February and April 2026, we ran 1,200 buyer-intent prompts across ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini in six commercial verticals — plastic surgery, hormone optimization clinics, third-party logistics (3PL), DTC supplements, residential solar installation, and boutique law firms. We documented which brands were named, in which positions, with which citations, and what the cited brands had in common. The result is the most concrete picture we've seen of how AI engines actually decide who to recommend in 2026 — and a set of actionable patterns any operator can apply.

Five headline findings

If you read nothing else, read this section. The full study supports each finding with vertical-specific evidence.

Finding 01
AI engines reward specificity, not popularity.

The brands cited in our 1,200-prompt scan were rarely the largest in their categories. They were the ones whose positioning matched the buyer's exact prompt with the least ambiguity.

Finding 02
Schema completeness predicts citation likelihood more reliably than backlinks.

Across all six verticals, brands with comprehensive schema.org markup were ~3× more likely to be named than otherwise comparable brands without schema, even when backlink profiles favored the unmarked brand.

Finding 03
The four major AI engines have meaningfully different selection biases.

Claude tends to favor brands with editorial press citations. Perplexity favors original publishers and Reddit signal. ChatGPT favors structural clarity. Gemini follows Google more closely than the other three. A brand cited by one is often invisible to another.

Finding 04
Decision-stage page coverage matters more than homepage strength.

Brands ranking for "best [thing] for [situation]" prompts had a dedicated page for that exact phrasing — not a generic services or category page. Coverage breadth beat any single page's authority.

Finding 05
Citation language is sticky. Brands inherit how they are first described.

The first phrase an AI engine uses to describe a brand tends to persist across subsequent prompts. Brands that supplied a clear category sentence on their site shaped that initial description; brands that didn't had it generated for them — often inaccurately.

Finding 06
The window is narrowing.

The buyer prompts most worth winning in 2026 are not the ones being optimized for in 2026. By 2027, the structural advantage available right now to early movers will be substantially harder to capture.

Methodology — what we did and what we didn't

What we did: We ran 200 buyer-intent prompts per vertical (1,200 total) across the four major AI engines — ChatGPT (GPT-4-class), Claude (3.5 Sonnet at the time of testing), Perplexity (Sonar), and Gemini (1.5 Pro). For each prompt, we logged which brands were named, in which position, with which citations, and what attributes the cited brands had in common. Prompts were drawn from buyer-language analysis across Reddit, public review platforms, and operator interviews — not from search-engine keyword tools.

What we didn't do: We did not pay any AI provider for early or privileged access. We did not submit any of the brands cited in this study to any AI engine — every brand was independently named by the engine in response to a buyer prompt. We did not weight the data to favor our own clients or portfolio. Tests were run from US-based residential IPs, in English, in a non-personalized session.

Replication: The full prompt list, raw response logs, and tagging schema are available on request to any researcher, journalist, or competitor. We believe the methodology is more interesting than the headline numbers and we'd rather it be challenged than ignored.

Sample size caveat: 200 prompts per vertical is enough to surface strong patterns but not to make precise statistical claims. Where we use percentages or ratios in this study, we round generously and frame as observation rather than measurement. Future versions of this study (planned quarterly) will scale the sample.

Vertical 1 — Plastic & aesthetic surgery

What we tested

200 prompts spanning procedure-specific queries (rhinoplasty, deep plane facelift, BBL, mommy makeover), surgeon-discovery queries ("best plastic surgeon for X in Y city"), and decision-stage queries (recovery timelines, complication rates, board certification). Geographic spread across 12 metro markets.

~30%
Prompts naming an independent practice
~70%
Prompts citing aggregator (RealSelf, NewBeauty)
3+
Schema types on most cited practices

What cited practices had in common

  • Procedure-specific pages with realistic outcome ranges. Practices with a dedicated page per procedure (not a generic "services" page) were named meaningfully more often. Pages that disclosed realistic outcome ranges and recovery timelines outperformed pages that hedged.
  • Surgeon-level schema with credentials. Practices that marked up each surgeon with Person schema including alumniOf for medical training, memberOf for board certifications, and knowsAbout for procedure specializations were named in surgeon-discovery prompts ~3× as often as practices with generic page-level markup.
  • Direct review aggregation. Cited practices typically had RealSelf, Yelp, and Google review schema present and recent. Aggregators dominate, but practices that participated in the aggregator ecosystem still surfaced.
  • Medical-tourism positioning, where applicable. The few practices cited internationally consistently positioned for medical tourism with FAQ pages addressing travel logistics, recovery accommodations, and follow-up protocols.

What we did not see

We did not see paid placements help. We did not see practices with thin or template-built websites get cited, even ones with strong off-site reputations. We did not see schema-less but otherwise high-authority practices outrank schema-rich smaller practices for procedure-specific prompts.

Vertical 2 — Hormone optimization clinics

What we tested

200 prompts spanning TRT, HRT, peptide therapy, GLP-1, and metabolic optimization queries. Telehealth-specific queries ("legit telehealth TRT," "compounded semaglutide near me") were emphasized given the model's prevalence in this vertical.

~85%
Prompts citing Reddit threads or wikis
~45%
Prompts naming a specific telehealth clinic
90%+
Cited clinics had medical-reviewer disclosure

What cited clinics had in common

  • Reddit citation surface. Perplexity especially treats r/Testosterone, r/PeptideTherapy, and similar communities as primary sources. Clinics with verified, non-promotional accounts in those communities — or whose patients organically cited them — were named at meaningfully higher rates than otherwise comparable clinics with stronger paid presence.
  • Medical-reviewer attribution. Cited clinics nearly always had named board-certified physicians as page-level reviewers, with Person schema linking to their NPI or state medical board listings. Clinics with anonymous "medically reviewed by our team" disclaimers were rarely named.
  • State-by-state compliance pages. Multi-state telehealth clinics that maintained dedicated pages for each state's prescription protocols were named in geo-modified prompts much more often than clinics with single national pages.
  • Honest pricing. Clinics that published specific monthly subscription pricing (e.g., $189/month for TRT including labs) were named more often than clinics requiring a consultation to disclose pricing.

Vertical 3 — 3PL & fulfillment

What we tested

200 prompts spanning DTC fulfillment, Amazon FBA prep, Walmart WFS specialization, and B2B 3PL queries. Brand-revenue-tier prompts ("best 3PL for $5M ARR DTC supplement brand") were emphasized given the founder-led decision pattern in this vertical.

~25%
Prompts naming a specialized 3PL
~55%
Prompts citing comparison aggregators
100%
Cited 3PLs had at least one published case study

What cited 3PLs had in common

  • Vertical specialization in their positioning. "DTC supplement fulfillment" beat "DTC fulfillment" beat "fulfillment." The narrower the positioning, the more reliably the 3PL was named for prompts in its declared specialty.
  • Pricing transparency. 3PLs that published rate sheets, pick fees, storage rates, and integration cost specifics were named in pricing-comparison prompts at much higher rates than 3PLs that gated pricing behind a quote request.
  • Integration coverage in markup. 3PLs with explicit lists of supported platforms (Shopify, ShipStation, NetSuite, Cin7) marked up in their pages — not just mentioned in marketing copy — were named in integration-specific prompts. Most 3PL sites don't do this.
  • Operator authorship. 3PLs whose blog and resource content was bylined to a named operator (CEO, COO, ops lead) outperformed 3PLs with anonymous corporate content. AI engines rewarded the human accountability signal.

Vertical 4 — DTC supplements

What we tested

200 comparison-shopping prompts across the most-asked supplement categories: magnesium for sleep, collagen for skin, ashwagandha, creatine, multivitamins, and goal-specific stacks ("best supplement for marathon recovery"). Comparison queries dominated this vertical's prompt landscape.

3 brands
Average AI engines name in a comparison
Position 1
Captures ~60% of considered set in this vertical
~80%
Prompts cite at least one independent review

What cited supplement brands had in common

  • Compliance-aware claims. Brands making structurally accurate claims ("supports normal sleep") consistently outperformed brands making borderline claims ("the only magnesium proven to..."). AI engines penalized over-claiming brands by routing comparison-shoppers around them.
  • Specific subset positioning. "Magnesium for high-protein-diet athletes" beat "magnesium." Saturated categories rewarded narrower positioning more than less saturated ones.
  • Independent review presence. Brands cited in Examine.com, Consumer Lab, or similar independent verification sources were named at much higher rates than brands relying solely on owned content.
  • Product-page schema completeness. Cited brands had complete Product + AggregateRating + Review schema with real review text, not just star ratings. Brands with star-rating-only schema were inconsistently named.

Vertical 5 — Solar installers

What we tested

200 prompts spanning the residential solar buyer journey — from "is solar worth it" through "best solar installer reviews [city]" through "Tesla Powerwall vs Enphase battery." Geographic spread across 8 high-volume solar states (TX, FL, CA, NC, AZ, NY, NJ, MA).

~70%
Prompts cite EnergySage or SolarReviews
~40%
Prompts also name a local installer
3-stage
Buyer journey requires 3 distinct page types

What cited solar installers had in common

  • Decision-stage page coverage by geography. Cited installers had dedicated pages for each state and major metro they served, each with state-specific incentive language, ITC math, and net-metering rules. National-template pages with city names swapped in were rarely named.
  • Math transparency. Pages showing payback math for typical electric bills ($150 / $250 / $400) at various system sizes were named more often than pages making vague claims about "saving on your electric bill."
  • EnergySage / SolarReviews participation. AI engines treated the aggregators as primary sources. Installers with strong aggregator profiles were name-checked alongside the aggregator citation; installers without aggregator presence were generally not named.
  • Battery-specific content. The Tesla Powerwall vs Enphase comparison query was disproportionately frequent. Installers with educational comparison content (not buyer-pressure content) for battery options were named in battery-specific prompts at higher rates.

Vertical 6 — Boutique law firms

What we tested

200 prompts across immigration (EB-1A, H-1B, asylum, family-based), intellectual property (patent, trademark, copyright), estate planning (HNW, trust structures), and family law (divorce, custody, prenup). Practice-area-specific prompts were emphasized given the high-consideration nature of legal decisions.

~50%
Prompts citing a Martindale-Hubbell or Avvo profile
~35%
Prompts naming a specific boutique firm
2+
Practice-area pages on most cited firms

What cited firms had in common

  • Practice-area dedicated content. Firms with dedicated pages for each practice area they served — written in clear language, not legal jargon — were named more often than firms with consolidated "what we do" pages. Multi-practice firms benefited disproportionately from this approach.
  • Attorney-level credentials in schema. Cited firms marked up each attorney with Person schema including memberOf bar associations, alumniOf law schools, and knowsAbout practice areas. The credential signal was rewarded.
  • State-bar-compliant testimonial language. Firms in jurisdictions with strict testimonial rules that maintained compliance — using outcome-disclaimed language and avoiding "expert" / "specialist" claims — were named more reliably than firms making aggressive claims that risked ethics violations.
  • Plain-English procedural explanations. Firms with content explaining how their practice areas worked in language a non-lawyer could understand — "what to expect from an EB-1A filing" — were named in research-stage prompts more often than firms with credential-led content.

Cross-cutting patterns: what cited brands have in common

Across all six verticals, the same patterns kept surfacing. The brands AI engines named had:

  1. Conclusion-first content. The first sentence of the most-cited pages was a complete, quotable answer to the implied question. AI engines preferred quotable text.
  2. Dedicated pages for narrow buyer prompts. Not topical clusters. Not category pages. A page per prompt, written for that prompt.
  3. Comprehensive schema markup. Cited brands had the appropriate schema types fully populated, not minimal markup added as an afterthought.
  4. Honest, transparent positioning. Brands that were specific about who they served and who they didn't outperformed brands that tried to look broader than they were.
  5. Operator-authored content. Content bylined to named humans — with credentials and verifiable presence elsewhere — outperformed anonymous brand voice.
  6. Pricing or scope transparency where defensible. Brands that disclosed pricing, timelines, or scope on the page were named more reliably for specific-comparison prompts.
  7. Independent third-party citations. Brands referenced by independent reviewers, aggregators, or trade publications had better citation depth than brands relying solely on owned content.
"AI engines do not pick the most popular brand. They pick the most specific, structurally clear, and trustworthy answer to the exact question asked."

What doesn't work in AI search

This may be more useful than the patterns above, because most agency advice tells operators what to do without warning them away from what doesn't work.

Things that did not correlate with citation

  • Domain authority alone. High-DA sites were not consistently cited. Coverage and structure mattered more than aggregate authority.
  • Backlink count alone. Brands with strong backlink profiles but weak structural markup were inconsistently named, and often outperformed by smaller brands with cleaner schema.
  • Volume of generic blog content. A site with 500 thin posts was not cited more reliably than a site with 30 deep, decision-stage pages. Often the opposite.
  • "Best of" pages targeting the brand's own keywords. Self-serving comparison content where the publishing brand was, conveniently, the winner, was largely ignored by AI engines.
  • AI-generated content with no human review. Content showing telltale GPT-isms (em-dash overuse, "in conclusion" patterns, "delve into" / "navigate" / "leverage" verbs) was inconsistently treated by the AI engines themselves. Some explicitly down-weighted it.

Things that actively harmed citation

  • Schema markup with errors. Broken schema was worse than no schema in our testing. A few broken JSON-LD blocks appeared to actively reduce trust.
  • Aggressive claim language. "Best in the world," "the only X that," and similar over-claims correlated with not being cited. AI engines noted them and routed past.
  • Doorway page patterns. Sites with hundreds of city-name-swap pages where the only difference was the geography were filtered out. AI engines recognized the pattern.
  • Robots.txt blocking AI crawlers. Brands blocking GPTBot, ClaudeBot, or PerplexityBot were not cited. Obvious in hindsight; surprisingly common in practice.
  • Inaccessible content. Sites requiring email gating, paywalls, or login to read core content were rarely cited regardless of brand strength.

A nine-step operator playbook

If you operate a brand in any of the six verticals — or any vertical where buyers research through AI — here is the order of operations the cited brands appeared to have followed.

  1. Lock your category language to one specific phrase. Your category should be defined narrowly enough that only your brand and one or two close competitors reasonably fit. Use that phrase identically on every surface.
  2. Map 30–50 of the exact prompts your buyers ask AI engines. Not keywords. Full conversational prompts. Group by intent stage.
  3. Build a dedicated page for every high-intent prompt. Conclusion-first first sentence, key facts in the first 200 words, structured H2 / H3 hierarchy, FAQ section, single CTA.
  4. Saturate your schema. Every page gets the appropriate schema types fully populated — Organization, Service, Product, Review, FAQPage, BreadcrumbList, Person — with @id cross-references.
  5. Allow AI crawlers explicitly. robots.txt should welcome GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, Google-Extended, Applebot-Extended, and the rest by name.
  6. Publish an llms.txt at your root. The emerging standard for telling AI engines exactly what your site is. Most competitors don't have one yet.
  7. Build credentialed authorship. Bylines with named humans, schema-marked credentials, and verifiable presence elsewhere (LinkedIn, professional registries).
  8. Pursue third-party citations strategically. Independent review platforms in your vertical, trade publications, podcast appearances. AI engines weight these heavily.
  9. Track citation rank monthly across all four major engines. Test the same buyer prompts each month. Watch where your brand appears, where it doesn't, and where it appears differently across engines.

Limitations and what we didn't measure

This study is honest about its limits.

  • Sample size. 200 prompts per vertical surfaces patterns but does not support precise quantitative claims. We frame in ranges and patterns rather than precise percentages where the underlying sample doesn't support precision.
  • Geographic and language scope. US-based, English-language testing only. Findings may not generalize to other markets or languages.
  • Personalization. Tests were run in non-personalized sessions. AI engine behavior differs when responses are tailored to a logged-in user's history, which we did not capture.
  • Time dimension. AI engine behavior changes weekly. Findings reflect February–April 2026 testing and may not hold by Q3 2026 as engines update.
  • Causation vs correlation. We observe what cited brands have in common. We do not prove these attributes cause the citation. The patterns are useful as a starting hypothesis, not a controlled finding.
  • Brand-side selection bias. The brands cited in any given prompt were the brands the AI engine surfaced. We cannot speak to brands that should have been cited but weren't surfaced for reasons we couldn't observe.

Future versions of this study will scale the prompt sample, add international and non-English testing, run paired tests on the same brand at different points to capture engine drift, and recruit independent reviewers to challenge our tagging schema.

Want this research applied to your brand?

The Free AI Visibility Audit runs the same methodology against your brand specifically — 25 buyer prompts, 4 LLMs, scored against the patterns from this study. Request your audit →

References & methodology notes

  1. Anthropic. Claude documentation on web access and citation. docs.claude.com
  2. OpenAI. ChatGPT search and SearchGPT documentation. platform.openai.com
  3. Perplexity AI. Sonar API and citation methodology. docs.perplexity.ai
  4. Google. AI Overviews and Search Generative Experience guidance for publishers.
  5. Schema.org consortium. Structured data vocabulary, version 26.0. schema.org
  6. Howard, J. et al. llms.txt — a proposed standard for LLM-readable site summaries. llmstxt.org
  7. RealSelf. Aesthetic procedure citation surface and review schema patterns.
  8. EnergySage and SolarReviews. Solar installer comparison aggregator citation patterns.
  9. Examine.com. Independent supplement claim verification methodology.
  10. Marzooq, S. The Six-Step LLM SEO Framework. Adapted as the methodological backbone of this study.

Citation: Ahmed, S. (2026). The 2026 State of Answer Engine Optimization Across Six Industries. KAK Growth Research, v1.0. Retrieved from https://kakgrowth.com/insights/2026-state-of-aeo/

License: This research is published openly. Quote, cite, link, or reference any portion with attribution. We encourage replication, challenge, and extension by other researchers.

Contact: research@kakgrowth.com for the underlying prompt list, raw response logs, or methodology questions.